1.5 An Elephant Makes Love to a Pig


An Elephant Makes Love to a Pig

Aired: September 10, 1997

This is getting to the point where I can’t remember if I have seen these episodes before or not. The fact that I can’t remember tells me two things. 1. Some episodes slipped through the cracks over the years. 2. Some episodes weren’t that memorable even if I have seen them.

I am pretty sure this is where we meet Dr. Mephesto. I always remember him as being a funny character, but when it comes to recalling why I think he was funny, I come up with absolutely nothing. I did read that this episode was originally intended to be called an Elephant F***s a Pig but someone had an issue with that. Not surprising at all.

Watching at home? Make your own score sheet for yourself at home by using our template here.

Character Score (Out of 3)

Stan – Composite: 2.05

Drew – 1.8: Stan was the subplot recipient again, a good role but very few laughs.

Matt – 2.3: Stan’s feud with his sister and the entire storyline with him and the clone they made of him made me laugh multiple times and I enjoyed Stan’s role here

Cartman – Composite: 2.7

Drew – 2.6: Cartman’s views on women were widely shared in this episode and it was non-stop laughs.

Matt – 2.8: The many times he said things about what he would say to a woman if she tried to do anything to him.

Kyle – Composite: 2.2

Drew – 2: Kyle and his science project were the focus of the episode. Some good laughs throughout the episode.

Matt – 2.2: Kyle is the one who had the elephant and the idea to breed the elephant with the pig.

Kenny – Composite: 1.1

Drew – 0.7: He mumbled, he died.

Matt – 1.5: Sounds like he tells Stan to have sex with his sister… Death: The Cartman clone begins to tear up Stan’s house and is swinging a chair and then hits Kenny with it. This sends Kenny flying into the microwave and turns it on. The clone is then killed. Kenny then falls out of the microwave and is burnt to a crisp.

Secondary Characters (Out of 10)

Drew – 7.1: Mr. Garrison’s quote was the highlight of the episode for me. Chef and Elton John singing together was masterful. Matt and Trey’s first appearance in the show made me laugh a lot!

Matt – 8.9: Stan’s Sister, Gail, Mr. Garrison, Dr. Mephesto, Pip, Chef, Elton John, Officer Barbrady, Stan’s clone

Composite – 8.0

Total Character Score (Out of 22)

Drew – 14.2

Matt – 17.7

Composite Character Score – 15.95

Episode Score

Relevance (5) – Composite: 1.7

Drew – 3.4: This episode aired only a year after the first sheep was cloned and it was a big societal debate. Add in the controversy of the episode title and there is plenty of relevance for this episode.

Matt – 0: Nothing I noticed

Irreverence (5) – Composite: 1.4

Drew – 2.8: The appearance of the special ed bus and Cartman’s views on women put this episode over the halfway mark in terms of irreverence.

Matt – 0: Nothing I noticed

Laugh Score (5) – Composite: 3.95

Drew – 3.5: Matt and Trey’s fireside chat, the pig and elephant DNA song, Cartman’s views on women, and Mr. Garrison’s role all brought the laughs.

Matt – 4.4: Mr. Garrison and the pig, Stan’s sister, Stan’s clone, Chef’s song with Elton John

Personal (7) – Composite: 5.5

Drew – 6: As mentioned on the podcast, Mr. Garrisons quote was a staple of my childhood as was the Napster audio file of Cartman’s view on women.

Matt – 5: This episode made me laugh and had a funny story line

SP Factor (1) – Composite: 1

Drew – 1

Matt – 1

Total Episode Score (Out of 22)

Drew – 16.7

Matt – 10.4

Composite Episode Score – 13.55

Favorite Quote

Drew – “Well spank my ass and call me Charlie!” – Mr. Garrison

Matt – “Yeah, if some girl tried to kick my ass I’d be like ‘Hey! Why don’t you stop dressing me up like a mail man and making me dance for you while you go and smoke crack in your bedroom and have sex with some guy I don’t even know on my dad’s bed!’.” – Cartman

Favorite Moment

Drew – The fight at the genetics ranch between Stan/Kyle and Cartman.

Matt – The baby pig comes out looking like Mr. Garrison and the kids get first place.

Total Score / Rank

Drew – 30.9

Matt – 28.1

Composite – 29.5 Current Rank: 4/5

Matt’s Review

Overall, this episode was enjoyable. It did end up having my first 0s so far, but the other categories made up for it. It made me laugh and it had a good story line. Stan’s clone and his feud with his sister made for him to have a quite humorous role in this episode. Kyle wanting to combine a pig and an elephant seemed to be the main story line and it made me chuckle. Obviously, Cartman had the one liners that make you literally laugh out loud. As a whole, this was a good episode.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: